July 23, 2019, 10:36:33 AM

News:

At the end of our life, we shall all be judged by charity. --St. John of the Cross


St. Thomas gives a classic pro-life argument.

Started by Geremia, June 17, 2019, 07:49:14 PM

previous topic - next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Go Down

Geremia

Super Sent. lib. 4 d. 32 q. 1 a. 1 ad 4 (=Summa suppl. q. 64 a. 1 ad 4):
Quoteuxor etiam viro leproso tenetur reddere debitum [...] et quamvis proles generetur infirma, tamen melius est ei sic esse quam penitus non esse.
 
a wife is bound to pay the debt even to a leprous husband [...] And though the child begotten of them be diseased, it is better to be thus than not at all.
Elige vitam.

Geremia

Another pro-life / anti-contraceptive motif is in St. Thomas's commentary on Matt. 19:18, where he explains why ☧ omitted mentioning the First Tablet's commandments (1st-4th, ∵ he know the rich young man already loved God), but mentions the 5th-8th, and explains why they are ordered that way:
Quotenon homicidium facies, quod est contra vitam in actu; non adulterabis, quod est contra vitam in potentia
Thou shalt do no murder, which is opposed to actual life: Thou shalt not commit adultery, which is opposed to life in potency
(Interestingly, ☧ didn't mention 9th or 10th, and so the rich young man doesn't lie in v. 20 when, although he committed the sin of covetousness, he says "All these have I kept from my youth".)

Existence (≡ divine essence!) is sacred! St. Thomas's pithy summary of the 6th commandment reminded me of that.

Elige vitam semper.

Geremia

Casti Connubii §66:
Quote66. What is asserted in favor of the social and eugenic "indication" may and must be accepted, provided lawful and upright methods are employed within the proper limits; but to wish to put forward reasons based upon them for the killing of the innocent is unthinkable and contrary to the divine precept promulgated in the words of the Apostle: Evil is not to be done that good may come of it. [Rom., III, 8.]
St. Thomas gives a eugenic argument in Summa suppl. q. 64 a. 3 co. (=Super Sent. lib. 4 d. 32 q. 1 a. 2 qc. 2 co.):
It is "a moral precept" not "to approach to a menstruous woman" "on account of the harm that frequently results to the offspring from such intercourse".

Geremia

Quote from: INPEFESS on July 01, 2019, 07:38:10 AM
Quoteharm that frequently results to the offspring from such intercourse".
Is this scientifically verified or was it simply a common belief of the 12th-13th centuries?
The Catholic OB/GYN Thomas W. Hilgers (inventor of NaProTECHNOLOGY) notes that, surprisingly, the most accurate method of determining the day of conception is if the woman daily charts her cycle based upon cervical mucus indicators, etc. (Creighton model / Billings Ovulation Method). The mainstream gynecology industry just assumes ovulation occurs on cycle day 14, LH ovulation test kits are worthless, and HCG (for pregnancy test) isn't high enough concentration until at least a week later. (Accurate timing of this is essential for NaPro's "Targeted Hormone Evaluation and Treatment" (cf. ch. 10 of The NaProTECHNOLOGY Revolution).) The second hurdle to such an experiment would be getting a large enough sample of women, because only a tiny fraction (probably <1%) would actually conceive outside the fertile window.

I don't think anyone doubts menstrual fluid is toxic (e.g., toxic shock syndrome is a risk of tampon usage). Else why does the body get rid of it?

cf. Pope Innocent III's On the Misery of the Human Condition 1.4:
QuoteBut notice what food the fetus is fed in the womb: with menstrual blood of course, which ceases in the woman after conception so that with it the fetus is fed inside the woman. The blood is said to be so detestable and unclean that "on contact with it crops do not germinate, orchards wither, plants die, trees drop their fruit; if dogs eat of it, they are transported into madness." Conceived fetuses contract the defect of the seed, so that lepers and elephantiacs are born from this corruption.

Geremia

Here's another pro-life quote (I-II q. 66 a. 4 "Whether justice is the chief of the moral virtues?" co.):
QuoteMaximum autem in his quae ad hominem pertinent, est vita, a qua omnia alia dependent.
in things touching man, the chief of all is life, on which all other things depend.

Go Up