Einstein’s Investigations of Galilean Covariant Electrodynamics Prior to 1905
- John D. Norton
- … show all 1 hide
Abstract.
Einstein learned from the magnet and conductor thought experiment how to use field transformation laws to extend the covariance of Maxwell’s electrodynamics. If he persisted in his use of this device, he would have found that the theory cleaves into two Galilean covariant parts, each with different field transformation laws. The tension between the two parts reflects a failure not mentioned by Einstein: that the relativity of motion manifested by observables in the magnet and conductor thought experiment does not extend to all observables in electrodynamics. An examination of Ritz’s work shows that Einstein’s early view could not have coincided with Ritz’s on an emission theory of light, but only with that of a conveniently reconstructed Ritz. One Ritz-like emission theory, attributed by Pauli to Ritz, proves to be a natural extension of the Galilean covariant part of Maxwell’s theory that happens also to accommodate the magnet and conductor thought experiment. Einstein’s famous chasing a light beam thought experiment fails as an objection to an ether-based, electrodynamical theory of light. However it would allow Einstein to formulate his general objections to all emission theories of light in a very sharp form. Einstein found two well known experimental results of 18th and 19th century optics compelling (Fizeau’s experiment, stellar aberration), while the accomplished Michelson-Morley experiment played no memorable role. I suggest they owe their importance to their providing a direct experimental grounding for Lorentz‘ local time, the precursor of Einstein’s relativity of simultaneity, and doing it essentially independently of electrodynamical theory. I attribute Einstein’s success to his determination to implement a principle of relativity in electrodynamics, but I urge that we not invest this stubbornness with any mystical prescience.
- Beck, Anna (trans.) (1983) [English Translation of] The Collected Papers of Albert Einstein: Volume 1: The Early Years: 1879–1902. P. Havas, consultant. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
- Beck, Anna (trans.) (1996) [English Translation of] The Collected Papers of Albert Einstein: Volume 4: The Swiss Years: 1912–1914. D. Howard, consultant. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
- Beck, Anna (trans.) (1995) [English Translation of] The Collected Papers of Albert Einstein: Volume 5: The Swiss Years: Correspondence, 1902–1914. D. Howard, consultant. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
- Becker, Richard (1964) Electromagnetic Fields and Interactions. 2 Vols. New York: Blaidsdell; republished as one volume, New York: Dover, 1982.
- Born, Max (1962) Einstein’s Theory of Relativity. New York: Dover.
- Darrigol, Olivier (1996) ‘‘The Electrodynamic Origins of Relativity Theory,’’ Historical Studies in the Physical Sciences, 26, pp. 241–312.
- Drude, Paul (1900) Lehrbuch der Optik. Leipzig: S. Hirzel.
- Earman, John, Glymour, Clark and Rynasiewicz, Robert (1983) ‘‘On Writing the History of Special Relativity,’’ PSA 1982, Volume 2. Peter D. Asquith and Thomas Nickles, eds., East Lansing: Philosophy of Science Association, pp. 403–416.
- Ehrenfest, Paul (1912) ‘‘Zur Frage der Entbehrlichkeit des Lichtäthers,’’ Physikalische Zeitschrift, 13, pp. 317–19.
- Einstein, Albert (1905) ‘‘Zur Electrodynamik bewegter Körper,’’ Annalen der Physik, 17, pp. 891–921; Papers, Vol. 2, Doc. 23.
- Einstein, Albert (1907) ‘‘Über das Relativitätsprinzip und die ausdemselben gezogenen Folgerungen,’’ Jahrbuch der Radioaktivität und Elektronik, 4, pp. 411–62; Papers, Vol. 2, Doc. 47.
- Einstein, Albert (1909) ‘‘Über die Entwicklung unserer Anschauungen über das Wesen and die Konstution der Strahlung,’’ Deutsche Physikalische Gesellschaft, Verhandlungen, 7(1909), pp. 482–500; also in Physikalische Zeitschrfit, 10, pp. 817–825; Papers, Vol. 2, Doc. 60.
- Einstein, Albert (1909a) ‘‘Zum gegenwärtigen Stand des Strahlungsproblems,’’ Physikalische Zeitschrift, 10, pp. 185–93; Papers, Vol. 2, Doc. 56.
- Einstein, Albert (1910) ‘‘Le Principe de Relativité et ses Conséquences dans la Physique Moderne,’‘Trans. E. Guillaume. Archives des Sciences Physiques et Naturelles, 29, pp. 5–28, 125–44; Doc. 2 in Papers, Vol. 3.
- Einstein, Albert (1911) ‘‘Die Relativitätstheorie,’’ Naturforschende Gesellschaft in Zürich, Vierteljahrsschrift, 56, pp. 1–14; Papers, Vol. 3, Doc. 17.
- Einstein, Albert (1912–14) Manuscript on the Special Theory of Relativity. Papers, Vol. 4, Doc. 1.
- Einstein, Albert (1914–15) Lecture notes for course on relativity at the University of Berlin, Winter Semester, 1914–1915. Papers, Vol. 6, Doc. 7.
- Einstein, Albert (1915) ‘‘Die Relativitätstheorie,’’ in P. Hinnenburg, ed., Die Kultur der Gegenwart. Ihre Entwicklung und ihre Ziele. As reproduced in Papers, Vol. 4, Doc. 21.
- Einstein, Albert (1917) Über die spezielle and die allgemeine Relativitätstheorie (Gemeinverständlich). Braunschweig: Friedr. Vieweg & Sohn; Papers, Vol. 6, Doc. 42. 15th expanded edition, trans. R. W. Lawson, Relativity: the Special and the General Theory. London’’ Methuen, 1954.
- Einstein, Albert (1918) ‘‘Bemerkung zu E. Gehrckes Notiz ‘Über den Äther’,’’ Deutsche Physikalische Gesellschaft. Verhandlungen 20, p.261.
- Einstein, Albert (1918–1919) Lecture notes for course on special relativity at the University of Berlin and the University of Zurich, Winter Semester, 1918–1919. Papers, Vol. 7, Doc. 12.
- Einstein, Albert (1920) ‘‘Fundamental Ideas and Methods of the theory of Relativity, Presented in Their Development,’’ Papers, Vol. 7, Doc. 31.
- Einstein, Albert (1920a) Äther und Relativität. Berlin: Julius Springer. Papers, Vol. 7, Doc. 38.
- Einstein, Albert (1922) Vier Vorlesungen über Relativitätstheorie. Braunschweig: Friedr. Vieweg & Sohn (Papers, Vol. 7, Doc. 71); translated as The Meaning of Relativity. Princeton: Princeton Univ. Press, 1922.
- Einstein, Albert (1949) Autobiographical Notes. P. A. Schilpp, trans. and ed., La Salle and Chicago: Open court, 1979.
- Einstein, Albert (1954) ‘‘Relativity and the Problem of Space’’ Appendix V added to 5th edition of Einstein (1917).
- Einstein, Albert (1956) ‘‘Autobiographische Skizze,’’ pp. 9–17 in Seelig, Carl (ed.) Helle Zeit – Dunkle Zeit. Zurich: Europa Verlag.
- Fölsing, Albrecht (1997) Albert Einstein: A Biography. Trans E. Osers. New York: Viking.
- Föppl, August (1894) Einführung in die Maxwell‘sche Theorie der Elektricität. Leipzig: B. G. Tuebner.
- Forman, Paul (1975) ‘‘Ritz, Walter,’‘pp. 475–81 in C. C. Gillispie (ed.), Dictionary of Scientific Biography, Vol. XI, New York: Scribners, 1975.
- Hoffmann, Banesh (1982) ‘‘Some Einstein Anomalies,’‘pp. 91–105 in G. Holton and Y. Elkana (eds.) Albert Einstein’’ Historical and Cultural Perspectives. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
- Holton, Gerald (1973) ‘‘Influences of Einstein’s Early Work,’’ Ch.7 in Thematic Origins of Scientific Thought: Kepler to Einstein. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
- Hovgaard, William (1931) ‘‘Ritz’s Electrodynamic Theory,’’ Journal of Mathematics and Physics, 11(1931–32), pp.218–254.
- Howard, Don and Stachel, John(eds.) (2000) Einstein: the Formative Years, 1879–1909: Einstein Studies, Volume 8. Boston: Birkhäuser.
- Jammer, Max and Stachel, John (1980) ‘‘If Maxwell had Worked between Ampère and Faraday: An Historical Fable with a Pedagogical Moral,’’ American Journal of Physics, 48, pp. 5–7.
- Janssen, Michel (1995) A Comparison Between Lorentz’s Ether Theory and Special Relativity in the Light of the Experiments of Trouton and Noble. PhD Dissertation. Department of History and Philosophy of Science, University of Pittsburgh.
- Janssen, Michel et al. (2002) The Collected Papers of Albert Einstein: Volume 7: The Berlin Years: Writings, 1918–1921. Princeton: Princeton University Press. (‘‘ Papers, Vol. 7.’’)
- Janssen, Michel and Stachel, John (forthcoming) ‘‘The Optics and Electrodynamics of Moving Bodies,’’ in J. Stachel, Going Critical.
- Klein, Martin J. et al. (1993) The Collected Papers of Albert Einstein: Volume 3: The Swiss Years: Writings, 1909–1911. Princeton: Princeton University Press. (‘‘ Papers, Vol. 3.’’)
- Klein, Martin J. et al. (1995) The Collected Papers of Albert Einstein: Volume 4: The Swiss Years: Writings, 1912–1914. Princeton: Princeton University Press. (‘‘ Papers, Vol. 4.’’)
- Kox, A. J. et al. (1996) The Collected Papers of Albert Einstein: Volume 6: The Berlin Years: Writings, 1914–1917. Princeton: Princeton University Press. (‘‘ Papers, Vol. 6.’’)
- Lorentz, Hendrik A. (1895) Versuch einer Theorie der electrischen und optischen Erscheinungen in bewegten Körpern. Leiden: E. J. Brill.
- Lorentz, Hendrik A. (1904) ‘‘Electromagnetic Phenomena in a System Moving with any Velocity less than that of Light,’’ Proceedings of the Academy of Sciences, Amsterdam, 6; reprintedpp. 11–34 H. A. Lorentz et al., The Principle of Relativity. Trans W. Perrett and G. B. Jeffrey. Methuen, 1923; Dover, 1952.
- Miller, Arthur (1981) Albert Einstein’s Special Theory of Relativity. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.
- Norton, John D. (1984) ‘‘How Einstein Found His Field Equations: 1912–1915,’’ Historical Studies in the Physical Sciences, 14 (1984), pp. 253–315. Reprinted in D. Howard and J. Stachel (eds.), Einstein and the History of General Relativity: Einstein Studies Vol. I, Boston: Birkhauser, pp101–159.
- Norton, John D. (1993)’‘General Covariance and the Foundations of General Relativity: Eight Decades of Dispute,’’ Reports on Progress in Physics, 56, pp.791–858.
- Norton, John D. (manuscript), ‘‘Einstein’s Special Theory of Relativity and the Problems in the Electrodynamics of Moving Bodies that Led him to it,’’ prepared for Cambridge Companion to Einstein, M. Janssen and C. Lehner, eds., Cambridge University Press.
- O’Rahilly, Alfred (1938) Electromagnetics. Longmans, Green & Co.; republished as Electromagnetic Theory: A Critical Examination of Fundamentals. 2 Vols., New York: Dover, 1965.
- Pauli, Wolfgang (1921) ‘‘Relativitätstheorie,’’ in Encyklopädie der mathematischen Wissenschaften, mit Einschluss an ihrer Anwendung. Vol.5, Physik, Part 2. Arnold Sommerfeld, ed., Leipzig: B.G. Teubner, 1904–1922, pp.539–775. [Issued November 15, 1921] English translation, Theory of Relativity. With supplementary notes by the author. G. Field, trans. London: Pergamon, 1958; reprint New York: Dover.
- Ritz, Walter (1908) ‘‘Recherches Critique sur l’Électrodynamique Gènénerale,’’ Annales des Chimie et de Physique,’’ 13, pp. 145–275; reprinted in Ritz (1911), pp. 317–426.
- Ritz, Walter (1908a) ‘‘Recherches Critiques sur les Théories Électrodynamiques de Cl. Maxwell and de H. –A. Lorentz,’’ Archives des Sciences physique et naturelles, 26, pp. 209–36; reprinted Ritz (1911), pp. 427–92.
- Ritz, Walter (1909) ‘‘Über die Grundlagen der Elektrodynamik und die Theorie der Schwarzen Strahlung,’’ Physikalische Zeitschrift, 9, pp. 903–907; reprinted as Ritz (1911), pp. 493–502.
- Ritz, Walter (1909a) ‘‘Zum gegenwärtigen Stand des Strahlungsproblems: Erwiderung auf den Aufsatz des Herrn A. Einstein,’’ Physikalische Zeitschrift, 10, pp. 224–25.
- Ritz, Walter (1911) Gesammelte Werke. Oeuvres. Paris: Gauthier-Villars.
- Ritz, Walter and Einstein, Albert (1909), ‘‘Zum gegenwärtigen Stand des Strahlungsproblems,’’ Physikalische Zeitschrift, 10, pp. 323–34; reprinted as Papers, Vol. 2, Doc. 57 and Ritz (1911), pp. 507–508.
- Rynasiewicz, Robert (1988) ‘‘Lorentz’s Local Time and the Theorem of Corresponding States,’’ PSA 1988, Vol. 1, A. Fine and J. Leplin, eds., East Lansing: Philosophy of Science Association, pp. 67–74.
- Rynasiewicz, Robert (2000) ‘‘The Construction of the Special Theory: Some Queries and Considerations,’’ in Howard and Stachel (2000), pp. 159–201.
- Shankland, R. S. (1963/73) ‘‘Conversations with Einstein,’’ American Journal of Physics, 31(1963), pp. 47–57; 41(1973), pp. 895–901.
- Sitter, W. de (1913) ‘‘Ein astronomischer Beweis für die Konstanz der Lichtgeschwindigkeit,’’ Physikalische Zeitschrift, 14, p. 429.
- Stachel, John (1982) ‘‘Einstein and Michelson: the Context of Discovery and Context of Justification,’’ Astronomische Nachrichten, 303(1982), pp. 47–53; reprinted Stachel (2002), pp. 177–90.
- Stachel, John (1984) ‘‘The Generally Covariant Form of Maxwell’s Equations,’’ pp. 23–37 in M. Berger, ed., J. C. Maxwell: The Sesquicentennial Symposium. North-Holland.
- Stachel, John (1987) ‘‘Einstein and Ether Drift Experiments,’’ Physics Today, 40(1987), pp. 45–47; reprinted Stachel (2002), pp. 171–76.
- Stachel, John (1989) ‘‘Quale canzone cantarono le sirene: come scopro Einstein la teoria speciale della relatività?’’ L’Opera di Einstein. Umberto Curi (ed.). Ferrara, Gabriele Corbino & Co. (1989), pp. 21–37; translated and reprinted as ‘‘‘What Song the Sirens Sang:’ How Did Einstein discover Special Relativity?’’ in Stachel (2002), pp. 157–69.
- Stachel, John (2002) Einstein from ‘B’ to ‘Z.’ : Einstein Studies, Volume 9. Boston: Birkhäuser.
- Stachel, John et al. (eds.) (1987) The Collected Papers of Albert Einstein: Volume 1: The Early Years: 1879–1902. Princeton: Princeton University Press. (‘‘ Papers, Vol. 1’’)
- Stachel, John et al. (eds.) (1989) The Collected Papers of Albert Einstein: Volume 2: The Swiss Years: Writing, 1900–1902. Princeton: Princeton University Press. (‘‘ Papers, Vol. 2.’’)
- Stachel, John et al. (1989a) ‘‘Einstein on the Theory of Relativity,’’ Headnote in Papers, Vol. 2 pp. 253–74.
- Tolman, Richard C. (1912) ‘‘Some Emission Theories of Light,’’ Physical Review, XXXV, pp. 136–43.
- Wertheimer, Max (1959) Productive Thinking. New York: Harper & Bros.
- Title
- Einstein’s Investigations of Galilean Covariant Electrodynamics Prior to 1905
- Journal
-
Archive for History of Exact Sciences
Volume 59, Issue 1 , pp 45-105
- Cover Date
- 2004-11-01
- DOI
- 10.1007/s00407-004-0085-6
- Print ISSN
- 0003-9519
- Online ISSN
- 1432-0657
- Publisher
- Springer-Verlag
- Additional Links
- Authors
-
-
John D. Norton
(1)
-
John D. Norton
- Author Affiliations
-
- 1. Department of History and Philosophy of Science, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, PA 15260, USA